Employment Workplace Relations

Director, Philip Brewin is a specialist in Workplace Relations and heads our Workplace Relations Work Group.

Corporate and Business Law

The Nevett Ford Corporate and Business Law team has a wealth of experience and expertise and have established quality relationships with clients, including many small and medium business enterprises, across a wide range of industries.

Dispute Resolution ( Litigation)

Nevett Ford has wide experience in all manner of litigation.

Mediation

Mediation is a process and set of principles designed to manage and resolve disputes between parties. It is an efficient and effective method of dispute resolution that can help to preserve relationships through the intervention of a third party, known as a mediator.

Property Law

Nevett Ford has been conveying Victorian property for more than 150 years.

Showing posts with label migration agents Melbourne. Show all posts
Showing posts with label migration agents Melbourne. Show all posts

Wednesday, 26 July 2017

457 Visa - Training Benchmark changes


Changes continue to be rolled out by the Department of Immigration & Border Protection (DIBP).  A recent change relates to the training benchmarks that 457 business sponsors are obliged to meet - this article explains how the changes impact employers.

Benchmark A - Payments to a Training Fund
This involves paying 2% of payroll to an industry training fund. From July 2017 payments may be made to one of the following:
  • Industry training fund
  • Fund managed by recognised Industry Body
  • Scholarship fund operated by Australian TAFE or University.

The following types of expenditure are now not eligible:
  • Funds operated by RTOs or private individuals
  • Funds paying commissions or offering refunds if application fails
The main impact of this change is that the previous practice of private education providers accepting payments for Benchmark A will be discontinued.

Benchmark B - Expenditure on Training Australians in the Business
This involves spending 1% of payroll on training Australians in the business. From July 2017 payments may include:
  • Apprentices, trainees or recent graduates
  • RTOs delivering face-to-face training which contributes to formal qualification
  • eLearning or training software
  • Formal courses of study + associated costs (e.g. travel)
  • Training officers - must be "sole role" of the employee (to train other employees in the business)
  • Attending conferences for Continuing Professional Development (CPD).

The following types of expenditure are now not eligible:
  • Salaries of staff attending training
  • Membership fees - this was previously counted
  • Books, journals or magazine subscriptions - this was previously counted
  • Conferences for purposes other than CPD
  • Hiring a booth at trade show, conference or expo On-the-job training - previously, structured on-the-job training could be counted in some circumstances
  • Training not relevant to business' industry - it is not clear how closely related the training must be to the industry
  • Training of principals or family members - previously, training of family members could be counted providing it was also made available to other employees
  • Induction training.

Based on current information, it appears that payment of external providers to deliver training for Australian employees, is excluded unless it leads to a formal qualification. This would form the bulk of the training expenditure of most businesses and so many will need to restructure their training to comply with the new Benchmark B. Once further clarity is available we will let you know.

What is also unclear at the moment is whether 457 business sponsors who have been calculating their training benchmark expenditure on the previous training benchmark provisions will be deemed to have satsified the requirement. 


We are awaiting further clarificaton on these points from DIBP and will provide further updates once available.

Calculating 'Payroll'
As a general rule, payroll includes:
  • wages and salaries as per state payroll legislation, and
  • payments made to contractors or subcontractors if the work completed is related to services or products provided by sponsor
If the business does not have ‘a payroll’ they are expected to count Directors' salaries, fees and drawings, or the profit of the business.


Timing of Training Activities
Payroll and training expenditure must be for the same period.


From July 2017, it has been clarified that this expenditure may be for the 12 months prior to lodgement of an application, or for the previous full financial year - this should help employers to gather relevant information and documentation.

Start-up businesses operating for less than 12 months will be required to show they have an auditable plan to meet these benchmarks.

We will provide ongoing updates as information becomes available, including the training requirements from March 2018 when the new ‘Temporary Skills Shortage’ (TSS) visa commences (replacing the current 457 visa).


Whether you are an individual visa holder considering how these changes affect you personally or an employer wondering how these and the further proposed changes affect your ability to recruit globally please feel free to contact us at Nevett Ford to see how we are able to assist. 

Thursday, 29 June 2017

Migration Changes: July 2017 - March 2018

There is a large number of changes to migration law from July 2017 through to March 2018. 


1st July 2017
  

Processing Fees

Processing Fees are set to increase in line with the forecasted Consumer Price Index. Visa fees will be indexed annually from July 2017 onwards. Indexation will not apply to the second instalment of visa fees. 
457 Visa Changes
  • Occupation Lists: The STOL occupation list will be reviewed and condensed further.
  • English Language Requirements: English language test exemptions for applicants with a salary of over $96,400 will be removed.
  • Character: Provision of penal clearance certificates will become mandatory
Additional Pathway to Permanent Residency for New Zealand Citizens
An additional pathway to Permanent Residency will be available from the 1st of July 2017 for New Zealand citizens who are special category visa holders, have been in Australia for at least 5 years, have arrived after the 26th February 2001 and can demonstrate set annual minimum income levels.

Up to 80,000 New Zealanders are expected to become eligible for Permanent Residency and applications are expected to be capped and queued. 
General Skilled Migration Changes
  • Reduction of the Maximum Age:  The maximum age for the Skilled Independent Subclass 189 visa is set to decrease from 49 to 45 years.
  • Revision of Skilled Occupation Lists:  MLTSS and STOL occupation lists are likely to be reviewed and some flagged occupations, particularly in the engineering sector are likely to be removed.
  • Limitation of Skilled Invitation Numbers: Occupations ceilings indicating maximum numbers of invitations that can be issued to the Skilled Independent Subclass 189 and Skilled Regional Provisional Subclass 489 visa applicants will be released.
  • State Sponsorship: Nominated Skilled State Migration programs will reopen. Many occupations are expected to be filled quickly and we recommend applicants to lodge their applications early. 
November 2017
New Temporary Sponsored Parent Visas
The introduction of the new temporary sponsored parent visa for bringing in overseas parents of Australian citizens and permanent residents has been postponed to November 2017. 15,000 visas will be made available annually. The visas will be valid for 3 or 5 years at a cost of $5,000 and $10,000 respectively.  The new parent visa will be renewable for a combined maximum of 10 years. 


December  2017
Employer Sponsored Migrants
The DIBP will commence the collection of tax file numbers for current 457 visa holders and other employer nominated and sponsored migrants. The resulting data will be matched with the ATO’s tax records to ensure that visa holders are not paid less than their nominated salary. 
The DIBP will commence the publication of details of sponsors sanctioned for failing to meet employer obligations.


Early 2018



Partner Visas

Partner Visa Sponsorship changes will not proceed as of the 1st July 2017. The new regulations proposed that partner visa sponsorship applications would need to be lodged under stricter criteria and approved before the overseas partner visa application could be lodged.

The new 2 step process is expected to delay the lodgement of the overseas partner application and require the overseas partner to have a valid visa until a visa application for the overseas partner can be lodged.The bill proposing the new regulations is currently before the Senate and as such has not been enacted. It is likely to not come into effect until 2018.
We recommend that our clients take advantage of the deferral of the new regulation and lodge their sponsorship and partner visa application prior to the 2018 changes.
March 2018
Pathways to Permanent Residency for Current 457 Visa Holders
 
Current 457 visa holders will no longer be able to apply for Permanent Residency under the Direct and Employer Nominated Transition Streams if their occupation is no longer on the long and medium term occupation lists. We recommend that current 457 visa holders take advantage of existing transition streams and permanent employer nomination schemes to lodge their application for permanent residency as soon as possible.  



TSS Program Replaces 457 Visa Program

From March 2018, the current
457 visa program will be abolished and replaced with the new
TSS visa program. The TSS visa will be comprised of a Short-Term stream allowing stays of up to two years, and a Medium-Term stream allowing stays of up to four years.

Short-Term Stream
 

The Short-Term stream is designed for Australian businesses to fill skill gaps with foreign workers on a temporary basis, where a suitably skilled Australian worker cannot be sourced. The Shot-Term stream visa is renewable only once.  The STOL occupation list will apply for Short-Term Stream applicants. 



Medium-Term Stream
 

The Medium-Term stream will allow employers to source foreign workers to address shortages in a narrower range of high skill and critical need occupations, where a suitably skilled Australian worker cannot be sourced.  Only the Medium-Stream visa holders may renew their visas onshore and may apply for permanent residence pathway after working for three years in Australia. The MLTSS occupation list will apply for Medium-Stream visa applicants.


Tighter Regulations
 

For both streams tighter regulations will be introduced including:
  • Increased Work Experience Requirements
  • Higher English Language Levels Requirements
  • Mandatory Labour Market Testing
  • Set Australian Market Salary Rates
  • Additional Character, Anti-Discrimination and Training Requirements.
Contact Nevett Ford Lawyer today for specific advice regarding your visa situation. 

Thursday, 11 May 2017

Budget Impact on Migration Program

Listed below is a summary of some of the budget announcements which will have an effect on immigration related issues:
  1. Annual intake; there is to be no change to the migration program numbers which will remain at 190,000 places for the 2017/18 year,
  2. Temporary employment visas; as announced prior to the budget there have been significant changes to the 457 scheme; several hundred occupations are no longer eligible for temporary work purposes, the 457 Visa will soon be abolished and replaced by a new visa to be known as the dual stream Temporary Skills Shortage Visa and only those employees whose occupations appear on the new Medium and Long-term Strategic Skills List will be eligible for transition to permanent residence after three years of employment with the sponsoring employer (previously two years).
  3. Training benchmarks; a levy, referred to as the Skilling Australians Fund Levy, will replace the current training benchmarks for employers sponsoring workers on 457 and 186 visas. From March 2018, businesses with turnover of less than $10 million per year will be required to make an upfront payment of $1200 per visa per year for each employee on a Temporary Skill Shortage visa. A one-off payment of $3000 will be required for each employee being sponsored for permanent employment under either the Employer Nomination Scheme or Regional Sponsored Migration.
    For businesses with turnover in excess of $10 million the payments will be $1800 and $5000 respectively.
  4. Temporary sponsored parent Visa; this is a new visa to be introduced in November 2017 with an allocation of 15,000 visas annually. It will allow the temporary stay of sponsored parents in Australia for periods of up to three or five years. The visa may be renewed from outside Australia to allow a cumulative stay of up to ten years. The sponsor (the Australian child) will be responsible for any public health expenditure incurred by the visa holder whilst in Australia.
  5. Foreign investors; A Foreign Investors Tax Levy of $5000 per year will be imposed on foreign investors who do not occupy or lease their Australian properties for at least 6 months of the year. In addition, other tax measures aimed at foreign investors -principally dealing with capital gains tax - have been announced.
  6. Age Pension and Disability Support Pension Eligibility; from 1 July 2018 more strict residency rules for new migrants to access Australian pensions will be introduced. Claimants will be required to have 15 years of continuous Australian residence before being eligible to receive the age pension or a disability support pension. Certain exemptions will apply.

New training levy for TSS and ENS programs from March 2018


From March 2018, employers wishing to sponsor foreign workers on the TSS and ENS/RSMS programs will be required to pay a training levy which will go towards the Skilling Australians Fund which will fund training of Australians in apprenticeship and trainee programs.


The payment for TSS visa holders will apply on an annual basis per employee. For ENS/RSMS applicants it will be a one-off payment likely to be collected on application. The amount of the new training levy will depend on the size of the business, to be determined on the annual business turnover. Businesses with a turnover of at least $10 million will pay more.


The training levies will be as follows:

Businesses with turnover less than $10m
Businesses with turnover $10m or more
TSS
$1,200
$1,800
ENS/RSMS
$3,000
$5,000
 

Tuesday, 8 November 2016

State of Victoria - Temporary closure in skilled applications for ICT occupations


Temporary closure in skilled applications for ICT occupations
Due to a large volume of skilled visa nomination applications received, applications for Information and Communications Technology (ICT) occupations will not be accepted from 11 November 2016 to 6 March 2017

The closure will be for a period of four months, however further updates will be provided should this be extended.

The occupations affected by the temporary closure are:

135112   ICT Project Manager
261111   ICT Business Analyst
261112   Systems Analyst
261311   Analyst Programmer
261312   Developer Programmer
261313   Software Engineer
261314   Software Tester
261399   Software and Applications Programmers nec
262111   Database Administrator
262112   ICT Security Specialist
263111   Computer Network and Systems Engineer

This temporary closure will allow processing of all outstanding applications and reduce the risk of delay for future applicants.   

All applications currently in process, and received prior to this date, will be assessed against current guidelines and an outcome will be provided in due course. 

Applications for all other occupations eligible for Victorian Government visa nomination remain open.

Note: Applicants applying under the streamlined PhD and 457 pathways are not affected by this closure and may apply with these ICT occupations during this time.

Monday, 7 November 2016

457 Visa - Who can Sponsor?


Who can become a sponsor?

To become a sponsor, you must be able to show that your business:
  • is a lawfully operating business
  • has no relevant adverse information against your business.
Australian businesses must also demonstrate their commitment to employing local labour as well as non-discriminatory recruitment practices.
There are two ways you can become an approved sponsor:
  • Option 1: Apply to be a standard business sponsor
  • Option 2: Negotiate a labour agreement.

Option 1: Apply to be a standard business sponsor

The standard business sponsorship arrangement is the most common way to sponsor a skilled worker using the subclass 457 visa program. You must lodge an application to become a standard business sponsor.


You can have only one standard business sponsorship approved at any given time (that is, one sponsorship approval per legal entity) which is usually valid for five years. You can apply to extend your sponsorship at any time during this five-year period by lodging a variation application.




The requirements for approval as a standard business sponsor differ for businesses that are outside and in Australia.




Business in Australia
You must attest, in writing, that you have a strong record of, or a demonstrated commitment to employing local labour. You must also declare that you will not engage in discriminatory recruitment practices.




Make the attestation and the declaration about your workplace record in your sponsorship application form.


You must also meet training requirements. This means you must either:
  • meet the training benchmarks if you have traded in Australia for 12 months or more
  • have an auditable plan to meet the training benchmarks if you have been trading in Australia for less than 12 months.
Business outside Australia
You must be seeking to employ a skilled worker to either:
  • establish, or help establish, a business operation in Australia
  • fulfil obligations for a contract in Australia.
If your business does not yet have an operating base in Australia, you are not required to satisfy the training requirement.

Option 2: Negotiate a labour agreement

A labour agreement is a formal arrangement negotiated between an Australian employer and the Australian Government. You might be able to enter into a labour agreement if you are in one of the following situations:
  • the occupation of the workers you want to employ is not listed on the Skilled Occupation Lists (Formerly Known as Form 1121i) or theAustralian and New Zealand Standard Classification of Occupations (ANZSCO)
  • you are a recruitment company seeking to sponsor skilled workers to be on-hired to another businesses, and the occupations requested are on the Consolidated Sponsored Occupations List (CSOL)
  • standard immigration options are not suitable.
You must be able to provide evidence that:
  • there is a genuine and systemic shortage of skilled workers
  • there are no suitably qualified Australian workers available
  • you have a commitment to training Australians.
A labour agreement comes into effect when it has been signed by all parties involved in the negotiations. A labour agreement is typically valid for three years.


How to propose a labour agreement


You need, among other things, to:
  • identify the relevant skills shortage in the business and why these vacancies cannot be filled by Australian workers (you need to show you have tried to recruit in Australia)
  • specify the number of skilled workers needed from outside Australia
  • specify the skill and English language requirements that relate to the nominated occupations. Semi-skilled occupations can be considered provided they are specialised and in demand
  • include copies of correspondence showing that relevant stakeholders have been consulted.
You might be able to use a template labour agreement if there is one for your industry or your worker’s occupation. A template labour agreement is a set of standard parameters for similar employers: it does not guarantee an agreement will be approved.


If the template does not suit your needs, you might be able to negotiate an individual agreement.




Labour agreements include a requirement to provide training to Australian employees.
When you have a labour agreement in place, you are an approved sponsor for the term of operation of the agreement. You can then nominate skilled workers from outside Australia under the terms of the labour agreement.




You will also need to meet your sponsorship obligations and any other terms and conditions specified in the agreement.  If you breach the terms and conditions of your agreement, we could suspend or terminate it.




Standard business sponsors

To sponsor a worker as a standard business sponsor, you must:
  • be a lawfully operating business
  • have no relevant adverse information against your business.
If your business is in Australia, you must also:
  • meet training requirements
  • demonstrate your commitment to employing local labour
  • not engage in discriminatory recruitment practices.
You can use Visa Entitlement Verification Online (VEVO for Organisations) to check the work entitlements of your prospective employees.

A lawfully operating business

You must be a lawfully operating business to apply to be a standard business sponsor. This applies to businesses both in and outside Australia.
To demonstrate this you must show both of the following:
  • your business is legally established
  • your business is actually operating.
A business that exists only on paper cannot satisfy this sponsorship requirement.
If you do not operate in Australia, you must be able to show that you need a skilled worker to:
  • come to Australia to establish, or help establish, a business operation with connections with a business located outside Australia
  • fulfil, or help in fulfil, a contractual obligation.
If your business is new, you can still satisfy this requirement if you can provide evidence that your business is in fact operating, even if this has been for only a short period of time.
Examples of the documents you can use to show that your business is legally established and operating are in the Document checklist.




If you operate a business under a trust arrangement you must provide details of the Trust Name and the Trust ABN when you complete the application form.  The application should be made using the name of the Trustee as it appears in the Trust Deed.




Details of the principals of your business such as Owners, Partners, Directors and major Shareholders should be provided when you complete the application form.




Contact us today for more information and assistance.

Entertainment Visa (Temporary Work) - Subclass 420 visa

The Temporary Work (Entertainment) Subclass 420 visa is for individuals who wish to work in the entertainment industry in Australia.



It is a temporary visa which is suitable for:


• performers in theatre, film, television or radio production, or a concert or recording

• people providing support to an entertainer or group of entertainers in relation to a


performing contract

• production roles


• people making a documentary or a commercial ( there is different criteria depending on


whether the product is for an Australian audience or for an overseas audience).
 

This visa requires sponsorship by an approved entertainment sponsor. Eligible sponsors include organisations, government agencies, foreign government agencies, or other specified eligible individuals.



This visa can be valid for up to 2 years and can be applied for either in or outside Australia.


Contact Ryan Curtis-Griffiths today (+61 3 9614 7111) for more information and assistance.

Monday, 20 June 2016

Sports Visa (subclass 421) - Australia


The Australian Sports Visa allows any professional or amateur sportsperson, judge or adjudicator who wants to visit Australia to participate in their field of sport.

Designed for sportspeople who are looking to improve the quality of sport in Australia, the Sports Visa allows sportspeople to compete in a specific event or series of events.

The Australian Sports Visa allows you to:

  • take part in competition or training in Australia at a high-level
  • compete against residents in Australia
  • exit and re-enter Australia for a multiple number of times (while the visa is valid)
  • stay in Australia and work in the nominated position (max. stay two years)
  • undertake activities in Australia in the nominated position (max. stay two years)

You can also include the following people in your visa application:

  • your partner
  • dependent relatives
  • dependent children
  • your partner’s dependent children

You may bring any eligible secondary applicants with you to Australia but all secondary applicants will need a separate visa application.

Short duration events

If you are competing as an amateur and playing for a club (usually 3 games), a Short Stay Business Visa  may be suitable. This visa is also suitable for judging or adjudicating a single event or match.

General requirements:

In order to be issued with a Sports Visa, you must meet a number of requirements.

You must be sponsored by:

  • an Australian organization that promotes sport/sport events; or
  • an Australian government agency or a foreign government agency

The validity period of the sponsorship is 3 years.

Nevett Ford Lawyers Melbourne can assist with the Sports visa application and regulatory requirements.  Please contact us for more information.

Australian Visa Update: Engineers Australia and skills assessments

For a number of visa applications it is necessary to obtain a 'skills assessment' from Engineers Australia.


For Australian qualied students with Advanced Diplomas this usually meant a full 'CDR report' as most Australian Advanced Diplomas were not on the Accredited qualications list which was regularly updated.


However, since the signing of the “Dublin Accord” all Advanced Diplomas that are recognised by the Australian government are also accredited.

Please contact Nevett Ford Lawyers Melbourne for visa assistance.


(Source: Engineers Australia)



Wednesday, 11 May 2016

Australian visa update: State of Israel - Subclass 462 Work and Holiday Visas


Legislative Instrument - F2016L00676 - IMMI 16/056Migration Regulations 1994 - Arrangements for Work and Holiday and Working Holiday Visa Applications 2016.


This Instrument specifies:


  • the state of Israel as an eligible Work and Holiday (subclass 462) visa country 
  • that a holder of a state of Israel passport does not need to provide evidence of government support for grant of this visa
  • the educational qualifications relevant to applicants from the state of Israel. 

Thursday, 7 April 2016

Medical Practitioner - You may be exempt to apply for a Skills Assessment if you hold a full and unconditional or general medical registration

It is a general requirement that any applicants who wish to apply under the occupation ‘Medical Practitioner’ will be required to provide an evidence of skills assessment.


However due to recent changes, the Department of Immigration and Border Protection is now accepting evidence of your full medical registration as evidence of a skills assessment.


Based on the current legislation, the definition of a ‘Full, unconditional or general medical registration’ will only be issued to the following two scenarios:


Scenario 1 – Applicant studied in Australia:

  • The applicant is a graduate of an Australian or New Zealand Australian Medical Council accredited medical school and have completed an approved period of intern training.
OR


Scenario 2 – Applicants studied outside of Australia:

  • The applicant must have successfully  completed the Australian Medical Council examination – including both the multiple choice questionnaire and the clinical examination
  • The applicant have been awarded the Australian Medical Council Certificate
  • The applicant must have completed a period of supervised training approved by a State or Territory Medical Board.
The Department of Immigration and Border Protection will accept one of the following certificates issued by the State or Territory Medical Board or by the Medical Board of Australia (MBA) as evidence of full registration:

  • A full, unconditional or general medical registration
  • Conditional specialist registration – this registration allows you to practise only in your particular speciality, with no further training or supervision requirements.

Conditional Specialist registration

If the applicant is an overseas trained specialist and the primary medical qualifications are not recognised in Australia, you are required to apply through the Australian Medical Council or Specialist Medical College procedure to have your specialist training and qualification assessed. The assessment will determine if your training and qualifications are equivalent to the Australian training skilled level and standard to be eligible to enter the workforce.


Are you an overseas trained medical practitioner that wishes to migrate to Australia? We can assist you with your skills assessment and further visa options. Please contact one of our experienced staff today to arrange an initial consultation.

Monday, 28 March 2016

Are you a skilled worker interested in migrating to Australia? – visit SkillSelect today

Are you a skilled worker interested in migrating to Australia? SkillSelect is an online system that allows you to quickly and easily enter your details to be considered for an invitation to apply for a skilled visa.


SkillSelect identifies overseas workers with the skills that are most in need in Australia. To find out if you have a skill that Australia needs, have a look at the Skilled Occupation lists on our website. Australian State or Territory governments will use SkillSelect to identify and select skilled workers that they wish to nominate for a skilled visa.  If you are nominated by a state or territory government, this will increase your opportunity to receive an invitation.


Over 39,000 invitations for skilled visas were issued in the 2014-15 programme year. 


If you have a skill that Australia needs and you meet the visa requirements, log into SkillSelect today. You may be invited to lodge a skilled visa application sooner than you expect.


Nevett Ford Lawyers Melbourne can assist with all visa types.

Wednesday, 2 March 2016

Applying for Same Sex Partner Visa

The Australian Partner Visa allows a person in a same-sex relationship with an Australian citizen, permanent resident or eligible New Zealand citizen to apply for permanent residency.

Successful applicants are granted a temporary, two year visa which allows them to work full time, travel to and from Australia and access to medical services.


After two years, from the date of lodgement of Partner Visa application, the Department of Immigration and Border Protection (DIBP) will assess your application and will grant permanent residency visa upon satisfaction.

Same Sex Partner Visa Eligibility

To be eligible for Partner Visa, you and your partner must satisfy the following:
  • that your relationship is genuine;
  • you and your partner are living together;
  • any separation time has only been temporary.

Type of Partner Visa Available

Nevett Ford Lawyers can help you to prepare and lodge visa applications, including:
  • Partner visa (subclass 309 and 100)

    This visa allows a partner of an Australian or eligible New Zealand citizen to travel and live in Australia.
  • Partner visa (subclasses 820 and 801)

    This visa allows a partner of an Australian or eligible New Zealand citizen to stay in Australia until an application for a permanent visa is lodged.
Australian immigration law is complex and subject to change.  It is important to obtain up-to-date information before applying for this visa.  


 Please contact Nevett Ford Lawyers for further information, assistance and advice.

Thursday, 11 February 2016

The back door to legal offshore detention


The High Court held valid a law which the dissenting judge acknowledges permits the Commonwealth to do outside of Australia what it can’t do inside Australia.

Parliament last year took the most unusual step of passing legislation retrospectively so as to sidestep the detention limitations set out in an earlier decided case of Lim. But for this, it would have been unlikely that the Government would have been successful in the challenge.

The High Court noted that it is lawful for Australia to make laws in respect of the removal of aliens but it is not within the High Court’s power to determine the validity of Nauruan law to detain those such aliens. There is a disjunction between the laws enabling the deportation of a person from Australia and the detention of that person in the land of another country (i.e. Nauru).

The Commonwealth used the back door to avoid the limitations set out in the Lim case by the natural disjunction between the laws of Australia and the laws of Nauru and invoking the powers of the constitution. In other words the laws permitting the removal of aliens from Australian is unhindered; just as is the ability of Nauru to make laws to detain these aliens. By enacting law (section 198AHA) to facilitate the joinder of the operations of each countries’ laws in respect to aliens it was found to have been within the powers of the constitution. What would not have been constitutionally valid was for the Commonwealth to pass a law that prescribes the detention of aliens in a foreign country.  

Therefore the real issue in contention was the validity of the Commonwealth to make law to facilitate and fund the ability of the Nauruan’s to detain these aliens, specifically the ones deported from Australia. The majority of the High Court held that it was within the powers of the Constitution (section 61) to make laws to facilitate these functions. However, the ability is not totally unfettered; it must be within reason and is ‘limited to action that can reasonably be seen to be related to Nauru’s regional processing functions.’

Plaintiff M68/2015 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection & Ors [2016] HCA 1